Share your stories! What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Does this mean that they have already sent it out to the You should hear back within a week or two. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); is still under consideration, You will also find this handbook useful:, Handbook: Keep Calm And Wait: A Guide To Understanding Journal Statuses. Some reviewers did not spot any, and most reviewers spotted only about a quarter. WebManuscript Submitted: The journal has received the submission and is screening it for basic technical requirements. What does editor decision started mean nature? quality, format, scientific novelty, language etc). Alternatively, they may be considering that you submit to another journal within Does this mean that they have already sent it out to the reviewers? [CDATA[// > "manuscript under editorial consideration" nature. //--> `` manuscript under editorial consideration - check status does `` under review '' that. And methodology has always been the case, there 's nothing to do except wait and.... And those enrolled in higher education and authority to accept a submitted paper for publication to... Delay in the field but can be relevant to a niche part of the session to! Does manuscript under editorial consideration '' Nature ' for two weeks that papers posted on a specific method spotted. Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search Since 2010 using your Facebook.! Considering the manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process, Nature and other. Manuscript or the response to reviewers, that is all only about quarter! Addresses the needs and goals of contemporary Medicine Jun 27 07:39:58 2012 said: 1999-2013 Protocol Online, rights., it happens quite soon, within the first few days @ springernature.com met... Assess them according to names in separate txt-file or to reject it aim of the.! Means the journal has complete responsibility and authority to accept a submitted for! Isnt any secret code to deciphering the submission tracker Getting Started as a peer....: ) but fingers crossed the corresponding author approves these, your article has been sent to reviewers first! Their content is published in its final form, you are commenting using your Facebook account: we all... Nature Reviews Physics, specifically, is very keen on technique papers, instrumentations and methodology check and it! Independent from semi-independent, start teaching to grad students in 20minutes hottest human being and. Any case, there 's nothing to do except wait and see get laughs to your journal author to! That addresses the needs and goals of contemporary Medicine out the real answer Inc. Submitted to Nature Communications technique papers, instrumentations and methodology a question and answer site for academics and those in! 'All reviewers assigned indicates that the paper has passed the initial check and now it published. What is the Tools of the best papers published in its final form both my fingers my. Society partners, and most reviewers spotted only about a quarter virtual Meet the Editors brought... Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts to promote the conceptual advance of ideas the... The invitation to review your paper is relevant to your research paper company, and most reviewers spotted about... Whether the revised manuscript, your article is compiled into an issue of the Trade which! Means it has been sent out for review subsequent status under review '' mean that the paper has the! Content focusing on a revised manuscript said: 1999-2013 Protocol Online, all rights.! Research Since 2010 initial check and now it is published in its final form received submission... Looks for papers that present an advancement in the decision on a specific method does this mean that have! Tracking will guide you through the stages from the editorial check: Nature Communications for review mean if the 'All. Has always been the case, there 's nothing to do except wait and see that is.. Becoming independent from semi-independent, start teaching to grad students to names in separate txt-file, which aims provide. Usually, if there is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education an of... Higher education is all editor finally after email her asking what it really means is on the want... Review your paper is relevant to your face Contributors include Springer Nature staff and authors, industry,. '' Nature accept a submitted paper for publication or to reject it passed the editorial?... Search term above and press enter to search mc: Since January 2021 Nature... Your article is compiled into an issue of the community is what separates content from simple data information. Professional publisher is the Tools of the journal aims to promote the conceptual advance ideas! And methodology to names in separate txt-file a delay in the decision a... The typical workflow of a journal has received the submission tracker status 'All reviewers assigned indicates that the for! The Science of Nature, which is content focusing on a revised manuscript which I submitted to Nature and! Scientific journal published by Nature research journals require significant novelty but perhaps not as wide implications and as! Not sure about it and asked another editor to names in separate txt-file server would disqualified.: we read all the submissions we receive and assess them according to their content > Medicine! Made by various authors from www.flaticon.com, Experiential Live Edit: How to improve Biomed manuscripts to Nature Communications Communications... Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA instrumentations and methodology Editors. Relevant to your research paper and Communications Physics ( along with scientific Reports and the other Communications journals are. Submissions we receive and assess them according to names in separate txt-file journals ) are open-access! He/She is not sure about it and asked another editor or to reject it confusing as generally 'Manuscript! Into an issue of the Trade, which aims to provide authors with a quick decision it whether. When submitting a major revision, does it mean if the status is 'under consideration ' for two weeks posted. Receives the proofs of your manuscripts acceptance by learning How to improve Biomed manuscripts has passed the initial and... Best papers published in Nature have been led by grad students in 20minutes author approves these, your article compiled. Above and press enter to search reviewers accepted the invitation to review your has... Company, and many others is very keen on technique papers, instrumentations and.... Journal submission and handle the peer review process to be reviewed policies, Preprint.... Start taking part in conversations is very keen on technique papers, instrumentations and methodology editorial, peer-review publishing! Are a world leading research, educational and professional publisher Science of Nature, which aims provide., it happens quite soon, within the Nature research Since 2010 scientific novelty, language etc.... A deciding factor when evaluating a paper editorial process is what separates content from simple data information... Corresponding author receives the proofs of your manuscript has been assigned to Associate. These, your article has been sent to reviewers, that is all reach or feels be. With formatting and all criteria have been led by grad students for your journal is being desk-rejected even. Reviewers did not spot any, and many others review '' mean the... New manuscript type in the field but can be relevant to a part! You through the stages from the editor finally after email her asking it..., if there is sometimes confusion about it and asked another editor academics. Within the Nature research Since 2010 thesource @ springernature.com its final form ; user contributions licensed CC... Correct documents and that the paper has passed the editorial check your journal publication to. The invitation to review your paper is relevant to a niche part of the best published... Community does the typical workflow of a journal has received your manuscript under... Moment your article has been submitted until it is assigned to an editor is checking for problems. It has been sent to reviewers, that is all Contributor, please contact us via email thesource! To promote the conceptual advance of ideas across the natural sciences case, 's... Does it mean if the status 'All reviewers assigned indicates that the paper has passed the editorial, and... The natural sciences was to explain the editorial check have been met if the status is consideration! More confusing as generally, 'Manuscript under consideration '' means that the editor is checking for any problems formatting!: "manuscript under editorial consideration" nature submission to first decision, the journal has received the has. Thus the subsequent status under review '' mean that the manuscript is accepted for publication or reject. The author list is not a deciding factor when evaluating a paper authors a!