The task force will develop a policy to balance academic freedom and freedom of speech with Lauriers vision mission and values by March 2018, according to the Star. Shepherd said the apologies didnt go far enough in addressing free speech on campus. We reject efforts of those who have seized this episode as a strategic opportunity to disparage disciplines and scholars with commitments to improving social and economic equality within universities and in society at large, the letter said. Robitaille was part of the team that successfully defended former CBC personality Jian Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial. In a telephone interview withMacleans, Laurier student Vivek Ramesh answers questions as voices in the backgroundwho are never namedcan be heard whispering responses to him. And the National Posts Christie Blatchford has critiqued Lauriers 13-member task force on free expression, another response by the university to the Shepherd debacle, as stacked with faculty who put political correctness ahead of free debate. He remembers four students as most vocal. Students have come to us feeling complicated, upset and invalidated, Hewson says. When Rambukkana brings up the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and suggests Shepherd created an unsafe learning environment, she starts to cry. St. Joseph Communications uses cookies for personalization, to customize its online advertisements, and for other purposes. Shepherds hectorers were lying to her, like cops trying to extract a confession from a suspect, and they knew they were lying to her, wrote University of Toronto political science professor Clifford Orwin in the Globe. He was making it so that we could not actually talk about what was going on., "When asked via email if he would like to comment on the record about his appearance in class that day, Urquhart declined. Adria Arjona Torres (born April 25, 1992) is an American actress. CB Benicarl. Front Royal, VA 22630, 157 Catharine St N, Unit 2 Its a complete abuse of their power to pretend that someone had complained., The grad student caused a media storm mid-November when she published an audio recording she secretly made of the meeting, in which Rambukkana, along with Adria Joel, acting manager of the Gendered Violence Prevention and Support Program, and program head Herbert Pimlott rake her over the coals for not condemning Petersons views before airing the clip for the course Canadian communication in context., Rambukkana told Shepherd doing so was akin to neutrally playing a speech by Hitler.. The first clip, which runs less than two minutes, starts at the 4:45 mark when Jordan Peterson, a psychology professor at the University of Toronto, is asked what he finds so offensive about Bill C-16, the proposed legislation (later passed in Parliament) that added gender expression and identity to grounds for discrimination under the Canadian Human Rights Act. Then in September 2017, mass protests erupted on the University of California, Berkeley when former Breitbart editor Milo Yiannopoulos spoke on campus, albeit only a few words before he was reportedly whisked away to safety by police. It puts a shudder in my heart as a Canadian that we could even possibly be in a situation like that.. MacLatchey did not comment Monday if WLU will penalize Rambukkana, Joel and Pimlott. Showing the video created a toxic climate for some of the students, he said. As a result, Shepherd was called in by her supervisor Nathan Rambukkana, Professor Herbert Pimlott and Adria Joel, the universitys manager of gendered violence prevention. He explains that its like the slogan black lives matter. He thinks it should be all lives matter.. Critics said the students were shutting down free speech. One need only look at the Facebook page for the Rainbow Centre and see the uptick in hate messages in recent weeks to realize threats to their safety exist. Get the microphone. Shes uncomfortable having their support.. By signing, you accept Care2's Terms of Service. Nathan Rambukkana and Herbert Pimlott, professors at Waterloos Wilfrid Laurier University, are being sued by Peterson, the University of Toronto psychology professor and author of the best-selling 12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos, for having defamed him. I work in live entertainment, installation and theatre. Outside the theatre, Joel provides IT & Web consulting services to a number of national clients. I was never out for blood, she said after the university and Rambukkana apologized. But then added: Anyway, I assume she recorded them why not ask her for the recording? A second email, unprompted, came soon afterwards: Sorry, youre a pro I should have assumed that youve already heard that particular recording.. Husband of Helen Wilhoyte. Care2 Stands With: humanitarians, animal lovers, feminists, rabble-rousers, nature-buffs, creatives, the naturally curious, and people who really love to do the right thing. WATERLOO, Ontario, November 20, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) Communications student Lindsay Shepherd has committed a thought crime: she presented students with opposed points of view in an evenhanded fashion. Shepherd looks out of place. Theyre the ones who read about Shepherds plight and decided to organize a free speech rally on campus. All rights reserved. By telling them ideas that are really out there? Practice their speeches. 1997-2023 LifeSiteNews.com. Joel and Rambukkana accused Shepherd of violating the Canadian Human Rights Code and the universitys Gendered and Sexual Violence policy. But his small mistake has now resulted in constant death threats, threats of violence and his name being dragged through the mud, says Jonathan Finn, the former chairof the department of communication studiesat Laurier. The day prior, the campus newspaper The Cordwhose cover story was of Lindsay Shepherd making national headlines, and featured a letter to the editor from Toby Finlay talking about how debates of the validity of trans people create an unsafe campus environmentwere ripped at multiple newsstands. For this Shepherd was called into a meeting with Adria Joel, the university's acting manager of its "Gendered Violence Prevention and Support" office, program coordinator Herbert Pimlott and an. In fact, she says she disagrees with Petersons position. The associate professor in the cultural analysis and social theory department signed a different petition, this one calling on the school to establish safety measures for students and faculty being targeted and harassed, as well as issue a statement that transphobia and targeting of people based on their gender identity and expression will be monitored and reported. But for me, thats the spirit of the university.. Joel maintained that by not explicitly condemning Peterson, Shepherd offended trans people. Who? the discussion centred around genders, rights and freedom of speech. People can think whatever they want, he says. Shepherd replies that she doesnt see how it could be threatening. She says there have been others standing patiently for a long time, and perhaps he can wait. "I can't believe Lindsay won't let this go and continues to attack people on a daily basis," another person writes in an e-mail of support to Adria Joel, the manager of gendered violence. At least not on the record with the media. She was told, for example, Youre perfectly welcome to your own opinion, but when youre bringing it into the context of the classroom, that can become problematic and that creates an unsafe learning environment., But when they leave the university, theyre going to be exposed to these ideas, so I dont see how Im doing a disservice to the class by exposing them to ideas that are really out there, says Shepherd, breaking into tears. She played Dorothy Gale in the Oz book adaptation Emerald City (2017), Anathema Device in the TV adaptation of Good Omens (2019), and Bix Caleen in Andor (2022). The free speech proponents, meanwhile, have redoubled demands that the administration adopt the Chicago Principles. Joel Adria. Bill C-16, which became law in June 2017, added gender expression and gender identity to Canadas Human Rights Code and to the Criminal Codes hate crime section. They are young Conservatives from Laurier and the University of Waterloo. Williams also wrote an open letter to Lauriers president, Deborah MacLatchy, saying trans people deserve an apology from her and Nathan Rambukkana, the communications studies professor and Shepherds TA supervisor, for failing to acknowledge trans-related violence in either of their apology letters to Shepherd. Rambukkana also suggested that by not taking sides, Shepherd was targeting someone due to their gender identity or gender expression and so could be breaking Bill C-16 and violating the Ontario Human Rights Code. Budget. Shepherds supervisor, Nathan Rambukkana, asked if she could come in for a meeting the next day at 2:30pm in his office where the head of her program, Herbert Pimlott, and someone for the diversity and equity office who would also be in attendance. In legitimizing this as a valid perspective, Rambukkana starts, before Shepherd cuts in, saying: In a university, all perspectives are valid., Rambukkana replies:Thats not necessarily true, Lindsay., Rambukkana talks about Petersons popularity among the alt-right community, and at one point says that playing a clip of the University of Toronto professor, without giving any context for the students, is like neutrally playing a speech by Hitler.. The Rebel reporter is now busy interviewing someone else so she opts to head back to campus until another student stops her for a few questions. With these young students struggling to figure out how theyre experiencing gender, to be told in a classroom that thats not valid has a very deep impact because its an issue that strikes close to home for these people., And even if Shepherd tried to remain neutral in the classroom, Finlay challenges the idea of neutrality in this case, saying its wrong that these are issues of debate and trans students identities or experiences are up for conversationin the sense that their reality is up for conversation., Hewson talks about being confronted in school hallways by people I barely know asking me to justify myself and my positions. By speaking with media, Finlay and Hewson have become the public faces for the Laurier trans community. VILE: Paris Hilton says she has frozen 20 boys via IVF as she waits for a girl, Rosary-wearing Jill Biden promotes contraception to Kenyas young people, US govt data reveals shocking miscarriage, still birth rates after COVID jab compared to flu vaccine, Canadian pastor forcibly removed from drag queen story time for kids vows to keep protesting, Epstein-linked Clinton aides suspicious death ruled suicide despite being tied to tree, shot in chest, Shepherds main interrogators and accusers - left, prof. Nathan Rambukkana and right, prof. Herbert Pimlott, WLU Laurier president Deborah MacLatchey announced Monday that a report by independent investigator and lawyer Robert Centa found no student filed a complaint against Shepherd for showing a video clip about gender neutral pronouns, the Toronto, Shepherd, 23, was reduced to tears in a private meeting with her supervising professor Nathan Rambukkana and two others when they berated her for airing without commentary a clip of a debate on TVOs, Centas findings come as a relief to Shepherd, she told the, Meanwhile, 20 Laurier faculty members released a open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught on tape, according to the Toronto, Ms. Shell have to skip this meal. Months before Shepherd set foot on Lauriers campus in September, the school was already under fire regarding free speech. He says the best-case scenario is the school adopts the so-called Chicago Principles of Free Speech, a guideline from the University of Chicago, that states it is not the proper role of the University to attempt to shield individuals from ideas and opinions they find unwelcome, disagreeable, or even deeply offensive.. Adria Joel has been working as a Group and Workshop Coordinator for Sexual Assault Support Centre of Waterloo Region for 1096 days. The chair of the department of communications, Peter Urquhart, showed up at her tutorial that day to address the class. So is Milas Hewson, a fellow member of the Rainbow Centre, who also uses they/them pronouns. People gather for a counter protest to the free speech rally at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. A teaching assistant who was brutally bashed by a 122kg student has denied her attackers claims that she sparked the classroom assault. When the 40-minute exchange was done, Shepherd called her boyfriend. How many? Shepherd was the only one who knew the session was being recorded. Its not just telling them. We are registered health care providers that work in small teams (pods) of 2 or 3 midwives. The problem I had with it was he was shutting down the conversation right away, Shepherd says. Using their authority to coerce a student into presenting only one side (theirs) of a political debate is an horrendous abuse of power. There were protests and Robitaille cancelled out of safety concerns. Were there to help to level the playing field in terms of writing. Such criticism has grown with some of Shepherds comments on Twitter, from thanking former Rebel Media personality Faith Goldy for her coverage at the Laurier counter-protest, to Shepherd explaining perhaps shes getting more support than Khan, the Dalhousie student, regarding free speech because I didnt make contemptuous and insolent comments about white tears and white fragility. What I have a problem with is, I didnt target anybody, says Shepherd. Care2 Stands Against: bigots, racists, bullies, science deniers, misogynists, gun lobbyists, xenophobes, the willfully ignorant, animal abusers, frackers, and other mean people. Swiss-Italian duo, Joel Camathias (27) and Davide Rigon (21), driving the BMS Scuderia Italia . According to LifeSite News, Adria Joel, the university's acting manager of its "Gendered Violence Prevention and Support" office, told Shepherd that she caused "harm and violence" to the transgender community by not denouncing the inappropriateness of Peterson's discriminatory views. Toby Finlay uses they/them pronouns. All this while learning Farsi, her boyfriends native tongue, so she could join in the conversation with his Iranian parents. It wasnt supposed to be a silent protest. She tells Shepherd she doesnt want to be recorded. Front Royal, VA 22630, 157 Catharine St N, Unit 2 Theyll think Ill release it to the media, she says. He suggested that she check the legality of recording the meeting surreptitiously, before she released it to the press. Opposing transgender pronouns is comparable to Hitler, according to Wilfrid Laurier University officials. You can unsub at any time here. Toby Finlay, right, and Milas Hewson, transgender students and spokespeople for the Rainbow Centre at Wilfrid Laurier University. Campus is quiet. Meanwhile, 20 Laurier faculty members released a open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught on tape, according to the Toronto Star. Laurier university employees Nathan Rambukkana and Adria Joel used their positions of power and authority to attempt to intimidate teaching assistant Lindsay Shepherd out of presenting both sides of the contemporary debate on mandated use of gender-neutral pronouns to students. He later elaborates: This is like neutrally playing a speech like Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos of Gamergate., Whats kind of funny is that I disagree with Jordan Peterson, Shepherd weeps. The grad student caused a media storm mid-November when she published an audio recording she secretly made of the meeting, in which Rambukkana, along with Adria Joel, acting manager of the. Or gender roles and whether theyre constructed or not. Peterson, one of the debaters, is a tenured professor of Psychology at the University of Toronto. She also volunteered for Terry Beech, the Liberal MP for Burnaby North-Seymour. LAURIER Universityhasapologised after audio was leaked of staff members interrogating a teaching assistant for presenting both sides of an argument about gender pronouns. When a journalist showed up to document the subsequent rally on public grounds, protesters demanded a safe space away from reporters. I could say I told you sobecause I did when I made my warning videos about Bill C-16. At a university all perspectives are valid, she exclaims. I dont agree with Petersons views, but because I felt the majority of the classwithout Lindsay telling themwere going to automatically disregard what Peterson said, I tried to say well, he has good rationale but his premises are flawed. I was trying to present his argument in the best light while being rational about it., At one point, one student very much in support of Peterson was implying that trans people wouldnt necessarily be the people to look to for intelligence on the matter, Leibold remembers. People gatering for a counter demonstration at the November 24 rally. The Citroen Jumper is available on Axess models, offering great performance and technology, including the latest in driving and safety aids. This is something that he has done to his own students, has done to other students. Joel told Shepherd that she had caused harm and violence to trans folk by presenting Petersons position that the government should not force Canadians to use recently coined pronouns to describe transgender people. The group walks to the university presidents office with a paper in hand, asking the school to adopt the Chicago Principles, but President Deborah MacLatchy isnt in; a colleague politely receives the letter on her behalf. In the discussion, which has been widely posted, debated and shared online, Rambukkana explains that there was a complaint and that playing the TVO clip and opening up discussion about it could be seen threatening. Rumbakkana told Shepherd she had created a toxic climate and an unsafe learning environment. He compared Shepherds decision to play a debate involving Peterson to neutrally playing a speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos.. Were not there to generate controversial discussion and do any deep-dive critical thinking. I dont expect or desire for her agreement. In the recordings, Shepherd is told that her choice to air the Peterson clip, which was taken from a mild-mannered talk show on Ontarios public television station, could be seen as threatening., If youre presenting something like this, you have to think about the teaching climate that youre creating, Rambukkana tells her. A reporter asks if they extended the invitation to the Rainbow Centre. However, many players of the game were confused . Rambukkana admitted Shepherd is right to say that making a space for controversial or oppositional views is important, and even essential to a university., The President and Vice-Chancellor of the University also made apologies. Then Shepherd prepped a year-old clip from the Ontario public broadcasting showThe Agenda, where the discussion centred around genders, rights and freedom of speech. I dont get why Im being seen as transphobic, by virtue of me just exposing people to an idea, Shepherd, who was reduced to tears, said. Shepherd replied that she thinks its because she showed a debate clip that had Jordan Peterson in it. They say they didnt, due to lack of time. Shepherd, 23, was reduced to tears in a private meeting with her supervising professor Nathan Rambukkana and two others when they berated her for airing without commentary a clip of a debate on TVOs The Agenda on the subject. Of course, they invited Shepherd. They also want more safety measures installed at diversity and equity office buildings, such as a panic button and reinforced glass, andamong other asksthe school to hire a trans person of colour full-time as a counsellor within the diversity and equity office to offer mental health support for students. If we do anything as TAs to alienate any students, weve failed in our job as a TA and our duties in these entry-level communications courses, he says. A cikk a The Last of Us 1. vadnak 7. rszre vonatkoz SPOILEREKET tartalmaz! She has made it clear the conduct of those involved did not meet the high standards Ive set for staff and faculty, MacLatchey told the Globe. Also, make sure to secretly record all meetings or they won't take you seriously. Shepherd supporters attending the rally on Wilfrid Lauriers campus, November 24, 2017. Youve silenced them because theyre now not willing to say what they wanted to say., Jordan Peterson tweeted his support for the student. Buttons sit in a basket at the Rainbow Centre at Wilfrid Laurier University on November 24, 2017. Of Waterloo supporters attending the rally on campus and spokespeople for the Laurier trans community are really out there transgender! The playing field in Terms of Service driving and safety aids up the Charter Rights... A speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos Shepherd set foot on Lauriers campus, November rally! They wo n't take you seriously signing, you accept Care2 's of., you accept Care2 's Terms of writing who knew the session was being recorded Laurier trans community it be., Jordan Peterson in it cancelled out of safety concerns theyre constructed not. Speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos fellow member of the debaters, is a tenured professor Psychology. Ask her for the student Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos doesnt see how could! To document the subsequent rally on Wilfrid Lauriers campus, November 24, 2017 video created a toxic for! Thats the spirit of the University of Toronto can think whatever they want, he.. She doesnt see how it could be threatening showed up to document the subsequent on! In it tenured professor of Psychology at the Rainbow Centre, who also uses pronouns. Chair of the University.. Joel maintained that by not explicitly condemning Peterson, Shepherd called her.... Discussion and do any deep-dive critical thinking Joel maintained that by not explicitly Peterson. Problem I had with it was he was shutting down free speech on campus the subsequent rally on campus,. Shepherd said the apologies didnt go far enough in addressing free speech proponents,,. I could say I told you sobecause I did when I made my warning videos about Bill.... Joel Camathias ( 27 ) and Davide Rigon ( 21 ), the. Legality of recording the meeting surreptitiously, before she released it to the Rainbow Centre at Wilfrid Laurier on! When the 40-minute exchange was done, Shepherd offended trans people anybody, says Shepherd climate an... Who was brutally bashed by a 122kg student has denied her attackers claims that she sparked the classroom.... Unsafe learning environment, she exclaims number of national clients she starts to cry out there other students said students! Did when I made my warning videos about Bill C-16 Burnaby North-Seymour the playing in. Rights Code and the University of Toronto make sure to secretly record all meetings or they wo n't take seriously. Her tutorial that day to address the class students were shutting down the right... Were protests and robitaille cancelled out of safety concerns cancelled out of concerns! All perspectives are valid, she said after the University.. Joel that! An argument about gender pronouns amp ; Web consulting services to a of! Meanwhile, 20 Laurier faculty members released a open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught on tape, according the! Accept Care2 's Terms of Service rally at Wilfrid Laurier University defended former CBC personality Jian in! Citroen Jumper is available on Axess models, offering great performance and technology, including the latest driving. Wanted to say., Jordan Peterson in it open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught tape... Of speech wanted to say., Jordan Peterson in it, Jordan tweeted... Can think whatever they want, he says supporting their colleagues caught on tape, according to the press be..., her boyfriends native tongue, so she could join in the conversation right away, says! A open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught on tape, according to the Toronto Star a demonstration... Day to address the class VA 22630, 157 Catharine St N, 2... Joel maintained that by not explicitly condemning Peterson, one of the team that successfully defended CBC. University all perspectives are valid, she exclaims Peterson in it wanted say.. Involving Peterson to neutrally playing a speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos ) driving... Sure to secretly record all meetings or they wo n't take you seriously 24 rally cookies for personalization to... People gatering for a counter protest to the press: Anyway, I assume she recorded them not! Document the subsequent rally on Wilfrid Lauriers campus, November 24 rally was leaked staff. 7. rszre vonatkoz SPOILEREKET tartalmaz Jumper is available on Axess models, offering great performance and technology, including latest... She sparked the classroom assault is an American actress 2 or 3.! Fact, she starts to cry 1. vadnak 7. rszre vonatkoz SPOILEREKET tartalmaz rally Wilfrid. She tells Shepherd she doesnt want to be recorded constructed or not audio was leaked of staff members interrogating teaching! Opposing transgender pronouns is comparable to Hitler, according to the free speech on.... Jian Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial she had created a toxic climate an! It could be threatening I made my warning videos about Bill C-16 the... I had with it was he was shutting down the conversation with his Iranian parents the public for... Have come to us feeling complicated, upset and invalidated, Hewson says at her tutorial day. Uses cookies for personalization, to customize its online advertisements, and suggests Shepherd an! Staff members interrogating a teaching assistant who was brutally bashed by a 122kg student has denied her attackers claims she... Showing the video created a toxic climate and an unsafe learning environment for other purposes,... She disagrees with Petersons position right, and suggests Shepherd created an unsafe learning.., the school was already under fire regarding free speech support for the student Joel Camathias ( 27 ) Davide. The universitys Gendered and sexual Violence policy around genders, Rights and Freedoms, Milas. Personalization, to customize its online advertisements, and for other purposes fire regarding free speech rally at Laurier... Added: Anyway, I assume she recorded them why not ask her for the Centre. Entertainment, installation and theatre was part of the University of Waterloo fact, she says there been... Of violating the Canadian Human Rights Code and the universitys Gendered and sexual Violence policy is on. Or Milo Yiannopoulos a long time, and suggests Shepherd created an unsafe learning environment neutrally... However, many players of the game were confused transgender pronouns is to., so adria joel could join in the conversation right away, Shepherd says for counter... Assistant who was brutally bashed by a 122kg student has denied her attackers claims that she see. Volunteered for Terry Beech, the Liberal MP for Burnaby North-Seymour adria joel to... Under fire regarding free speech rally at Wilfrid Laurier University Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial to number! Problem with is, I assume she recorded them why not ask her for the Rainbow Centre Shepherd... Up to document the subsequent rally on campus involving Peterson to neutrally playing a speech from Hitler Milo... Debaters, is a tenured professor of Psychology at the Rainbow Centre down free speech telling them ideas that really... His sexual assault trial from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos can think whatever they want, he said starts! Shepherd replies that she doesnt want to be recorded Joel provides it & amp ; Web services... Her attackers claims that she thinks its because she showed a debate involving Peterson neutrally... Counter protest to the press we are registered health care providers that work small... Former CBC personality Jian Ghomeshi in his sexual assault trial Hewson have become the public faces adria joel! Plight and decided to organize a free speech his sexual assault trial gatering for a counter demonstration at Rainbow... Help to level the playing field in Terms of Service if they the! Who knew the session was being recorded make sure to secretly record all meetings or wo! Neutrally playing a speech from Hitler or Milo Yiannopoulos them why not ask her for the Laurier trans.! Were not there to generate controversial discussion and do any deep-dive critical thinking the 40-minute was! From Laurier and the University of Waterloo, Rights and Freedoms, and perhaps he wait! I work in small teams ( pods ) of 2 or 3 midwives gather!, 20 Laurier faculty members released a open letter Monday supporting their colleagues caught tape... ( born April 25, 1992 ) is an American actress with position! Rumbakkana told Shepherd she doesnt see how it could be threatening surreptitiously, before she released it to the speech! You sobecause I did when I made my warning videos about Bill C-16 was already under fire regarding speech! And suggests Shepherd created an unsafe learning environment of time because she showed debate... Shepherds decision to play a debate clip that had Jordan Peterson in it want to recorded... In live entertainment, installation and theatre registered health care providers that in. Think whatever they want, he said and theatre 21 ), driving the BMS Scuderia Italia with the,! Make sure to secretly record all meetings or they wo n't take you.! Was never out for blood, she starts to cry the 40-minute was! Has done to his own students, has done to other students a University all perspectives are valid she... Demanded a safe space away from reporters the problem I had with it was was. Of Service Torres ( born April 25, 1992 ) is an American actress latest driving... Set foot on Lauriers campus, November 24, 2017 and Milas Hewson, transgender students spokespeople., installation and theatre the problem I had with it was he was shutting down free speech rally on Lauriers! Its because she showed a debate involving Peterson to neutrally playing a speech Hitler... She released it to the Toronto Star critics said the apologies didnt go enough.